Hey Sumatra! Thanks for the feedback! Allow me to address some of your points (both the negatives and positives).
Sumatra wrote:Positives were interesting technology. Problem with it was it's too powerful, doubled as a negative for me. Why would Max waste two of these things on a rival and her assistant when he's failed so many times with Ms. Metrobay? Think a member of the squad would have been a higher priority for this.
Max Indeks isn't the type to want to mind control the whole city; he likes to see his victims resist and squirm when he ties them up and has his fun with them. He also knows that, without complete proof, he's simply too powerful and the city too corrupt to allow the Squad to get the better of him, and he relishes this power. It's the same reason that he let heroines under his control, like Hypnotica, Solaria, and Snowflake, go... so he can play the "game" with them another day. Max will not "permanently" control someone unless it's for a very good reason... and this story had one. Max has no desire to permanently enslave Ms. Metrobay or even Pink Pussycat... he WANTS them to challenge him again and again and to lose so he can have his kinky fun with them over and over. In more blunt terms, the fun of the game is in the hunt itself.
The "nano-leash" enslavement requires a lot of resources. Max outright states that they didn't have enough to enslave Violet Star with one, so he saved it for the one that really needed it. The only reason Nicole was chosen first was because they needed a test subject to ensure it DID work on the "bigger prize" that was Andrea. Andrea was too public, too valuable, and too well-known to risk any mistakes... and APEX HAS made many mistakes before (Super Freak comes to mind). Max was being cautious. I'll explain why I chose this method instead of the others down below...
Another positive, interaction between Andrea and Nicole. Also Andrea's conversion was done well.
You'll continue to see interactions between them. Glad you enjoyed Andrea's conversion too!
Negatives were the storytelling. Andrea was ultimately a plot device to introduce "new" heroine Onyx.
Andrea's role in this is far from over. Onyx is certainly going to be very important too, but Andrea's one of the most popular and powerful superheroines in the business... and now she's in league with the Squad's biggest enemy. That status is going to haunt Onyx and the rest of the Squad for a very, very long time to come.
Again. Why would Max go to this much trouble with this OP technology just for a rival, while the mayor functions for months or years now wearing a greentooth earpiece? They first thought Andrea and Nicole were both civvies, so why not just greentooth them? It's hidden. Tried and true. If that fails just put a ring on her like Love and Obey.
MacroLass summed it up perfectly. Andrea was far from a simple "rival". She was an outright THREAT. She was about to strip him from his pedestal of power and glory and take away everything that he values. This was the first time Max has ever encountered someone who, in all honestly, was just more influential and powerful than he was. It was a hostile takeover, and Max was made desperate.
Because this was so big of a threat, that's why the "nano-leash" was involved. Like you said, it's powerful and effective. Possibly too powerful (and hence why it's limited and another will take time to create). The reason another method wasn't used is because those carry the risk of removal. How many times has a greentooth been shaken loose? How many times have they taken one off to take a shower or go to bed? Even the rings from Love and Obey can simply be removed, and we saw how the heroines responded to their captors after getting their minds back (ouch!). Those devices carried with them a bit of a risk that Max knew he simply couldn't afford. If a ring or a greentooth on her was removed, Andrea would come gunning for him. There's even a very good reason why Max has used secondary-parties to enslave others, while in this case he was forced into a confrontation due to Andrea's public statements. This method will ensure no heroine can easily free her, and thus, in Max's minds, it settles the matter for GOOD. No risks, no fears... it's a problem dealt with. Now he can go back to his fun and games with rings and greentooths.
Max with his own superheroine force was too far fetched. He gets hounded by the squad every arc, why draw more attention? He should have used Andrea to set a deeper cover story and run her business quiet from the inside. As it is, it makes the squad look dumb as hell, no offense.
Max Indeks may not be loved by the Squad, but the people of Metrobay by and large ADORE Max and view him as a great humanitarian that has given much to the city of Metrobay. The citizens of Metrobay look up to and admire him. Men wish to be him, women wish to be with him. He's popular and well-liked.
Max has now leveraged his popularity and resources into his own squad, "generously" funding the creation of a superhero group that already has Metrobay's citizens comparing the Superheroine Squad unfavorably to. Max's goal is not to FIGHT the Superheroine Squad; the APEX Alliance will be going about doing the same job the Squad does... and possibly better. Heroines like Azure Avenger are world-renown. Valiant Girl is a Metrobay legend. Max loves to humiliate his opponents, and the Squad is going to have trouble looking good to the public when Max's APEX Alliance is being shown getting the job done and looking far more competent than they ever have. There's a reason page 102 has Andrea stating Max set up a villain for her to capture so she looks good to the public. It's another game for Max... his "heroines" are shown to be competently arresting criminals he himself employs, while his connections to the Funhouse allows them to escape again. Meanwhile, the Squad is continuing their misadventures of being tied up, outsmarted, and mind controlled.
It's all one big deception to the public. Max's heroines are "getting the job done" while Max is painting the Squad as "incompetent" and continuing to sway public opinion to his side. In many ways, that's why I feel he's one of the most dangerous adversaries the Squad has faced. He attacks them indirectly, subversively, and can manipulate the public at large into turning against these selfless heroines of justice. It's all part of his game, and now Andrea can't threaten it by taking over his playground.