
I have a serious love/hate relationship with Ms. Metrobay. I have a lot of material to go over, so *cracks knuckles* let's get down and dirty.
I'll start with all the positives.
Ms. Metrobay is insanely professional. She's got a level of maturity that's sorely lacking in nearly every other heroine. Even top-level, popular heroines like Pink Pussycat, Valient Grrl, and Omega Woman are rather childish and immature at times. Not Ms. Metrobay. That woman is the most level-headed woman in the whole damn city, and for that alone it's easy to see how, even though she sort of got dragged into the heroine business, she's the one that had the chops to rise above and take over leadership responsibilities. With her age and experience, she acts like nothing phases her; robots, wizards, aliens, mutants, clones, mad scientists... she's seen it all.
Secondly, she's got a familial side. Her status as a mother is one that I enjoy beyond all others, and I'm actually a tad upset that's not brought up and addressed more often. Ms. Metrobay's crusade against evil isn't just an occupation she did because she had some gifts; that's what most heroines do. Kelly's leadership position is a PERSONAL thing. She's out there fighting, not because she wants to, but because her daughter is in danger every second of the day and she feels she has no right to do anything less. I'm sure she'd much rather retire quietly and spend her time with Alpha Man in his golden years; he may be a hardy man, but at his age, I'm sure every moment away from him is precious time they may not be able to make up later. But she's out there fighting anyway, for friends and family.
Her maternal instincts extend beyond that to the other heroines. As a mother, no heroine is better equipped to help young, fledgling heroines learn and grow and to nurture their powers and abilities. She's the direct mother of Alpha Woman, but you could call her the "mother" of the entire Squad, caring for their well-being, being stern when needed, and giving them the means necessary to grow as individuals. That's a vital role she performs that's rarely addressed.
But I have a few problems with her too.
For starters, and I'm going to be blunt here, as a heroine... she sucks. Yeah, she's this old, legendary heroine that fills out a costume, but in action she's done almost nothing to warrant all that praise and respect. Silver Satin has saved the day more than Ms. Metrobay has and she's just a fledgling, novice rookie. In battle, Valient Grrl and Omega Woman can bark out orders while throwing themselves at the main threats. Ms. Metrobay should be one of the most hardy heroines on the team, but it's like she doesn't want to mess her hair or break a nail. She sort of tends to show up late, promptly gets mind controlled, and does nothing, except perhaps accidentally help save the day by distracting an enemy with her big breasts or causing milk tanks to explode with her big breasts (her breasts are more heroic than she is...) I can't even name the last time Ms. Metrobay actually used her powers in any context that would be considered "heroic"...
Secondly, she may be the "protagonist"... but there are dozens of other heroines that could be used as well, many of whom I find vastly more interesting and full of potential than Ms. Metrobay. Kelly didn't even show up until after Valient Grrl, Alpha Woman, Brown Sugar, and Silver Satin were shown, to say nothing of Pink Pussycat, Clawdette, Kitten, Valiant Girl/Woman, or Nightengale. I KNOW writers like using her (and her big breasts), but she's everywhere, even in stories that could BENEFIT from having her role filled with someone else, if only for variety and diversity's sake. The fact that LISA, her robot clone, is being heavily played around right now doesn't help; it almost feels like there's twice as much Ms. Metrobay now as before and it's a little overbearing for my personal tastes (and it's one of the reasons I'm taking a break from Valient Grrl and Hypnotica stories following the completion of my own... I just NEED something new to work with).
Moreover, and this is my personal opinion, I'm still missing her debut outfit. You know, the one that actually shows off her skin, cleavage, and sexy legs. I know Ms. Metrobay changes costumes every now and then, but I definitely prefer her very first outfit compared to her current costume... which is just Alpha Woman's with a different color scheme (and even though it was retconned into Alpha Woman stealing MM's costume, as readers we saw AW's first). For a woman with such a breast-centric persona, losing that cleavage and covering up her chest was like putting fabric over Power Girl's cleavage-window or throwing jeans over Black Canary's fishnet stockings. It takes away from Alpha Woman's uniqueness and makes both outfits seem generic (maybe Alpha Woman could change outfits rather than feel like a copy of her mother in every instance.) Beyond that, and maybe I'm just jaded, but I'm just not a fan of blonde, bimbo Barbie types with big boobs (unless they have great personalities, like Snowflake); I'd much rather see more Jade Lightning, Brown Sugar, RollerGrrl, or even Super Freak going out and getting more action. I wouldn't even mind something fun like Akonkid's Gorilla Gal popping up for appearances if it meant more variety or a change from Ms. Metrobay.
Lastly, Ms. Metrobay has SO much potential. That's the criminal thing; I'm honestly eager to see something new, be it other heroines preferably, but I'd just as readily like to see something new done with Ms. Metrobay herself. She has all this history that's unexplored; a past with Omega Woman that's hinted at but never touched upon; a daughter she co-leads with but spends less time with than she does with Ted... there's so many stories that COULD be told, be it flashbacks to her adventures with Alpha Man or stories that call for her to make legitimately important leadership decisions that might cost them or just ANY story of her showing she's not some trophy heroine, going out, and getting her hands dirty. I loved scenes of Marcy kicking robot butt in "Superheroine Squad", of Valient Grrl crawling out of rubble in "Body Image" or fighting robots in "Hypnotica", of Alpha Woman scaring the beejezus out of the badguys with her powers in "Platinum Earth", of Jade Lightning and Brown Sugar learning how to fight in Duality Dame's story, and Snowflake proving her mettle in "Resort Tales". But Ms. Metrobay doesn't have any story I can point to and go "damn! She's awesome!" She's not. She's pretty. That's it. Omega Woman is flying around blasting robots with eye lasers, Mechana is calling out for Sentius's blood, Kitten is punching out scumbags, and Enchantress is using her magic to bust crime... but their grand leader just isn't acting very "super" in the "Superheroine Squad".
But I don't want too end this one a negative. I gave her a healthy 4 out of 5 because she DOES have so much going for her and she has done so much very right. She's important to the Squad, and her beauty does warrant the almost zealotry praise everyone heaps on her (I wonder if there is a "cult of Ms. Metrobay" somewhere...). She's got a huge family that's fun to visit and deal with, she's got great powers she can use, she's got a huge amount of history to read over and potential to explore. She's got class and she never fails to provide the eroticism whenever she shows up.
It's a GOOD character that makes fans wish there was more done with her. If she was a lame character, people wouldn't care or wouldn't even notice. But for Ms. Metrobay, she's in so many stories and does so much right that her flaws stand out more than most. Personally, I'd like to see more stories dealing with her absence to show us WHY she is so necessary; like, we never really got Alpha Woman's feelings on that time her mother dropped off the planet, ditched her father without a word, and left her in charge of running an entire team of superheroes... you'd think that could be addressed at some point. Or Omega Woman dealing with their decades of prior history, and how both of them can relate as women originating from a different era, one before cell phones, home computers, or even color TV. There's just such richness to her character, such potential, such promise, that I find it a shame she keeps showing up to do the same things over and over; she has much much more to offer than just being the biggest pair of tits in Metrobay.